'Big business once cherished workers. Now it exploits them' Spectator Life - 21 Feb 18

Victorian capitalists belonged to the same town as those who worked for them. They could not escape the demands of the neighbourhood.

After two decades in which it was assumed that the argument was over, capitalism has resurged at the top of the political agenda. Is it the key to prosperity or the solvent of communities? Is it the source of inequalities or the cure for them, the path to stability or the sure way to a crisis? And is there, given what we know of the old ‘socialist economies’, a real alternative?


The term ‘capitalism’ was introduced by Saint-Simon to describe any economy in which privately owned firms compete in a market, the owners take the profits and the workers take a wage. But the owner-worker distinction has been eroded, and wages are now only one aspect of the deal between them. Marx depicted ruthless capitalists driving down wages to the lowest level while competing for the largest possible market share. But that picture was never accurate. Wages were rising throughout the first half of the 19th century; factory legislation governing the hours of work, and the provision of healthcare and education, changed the structure of the wage contract, while employers began to accept what Disraeli called ‘the feudal principle’; that the relation between employer and employee is a fiduciary one, in which the parties are tied by reciprocal duties — hence, among many other things, the model towns of Saltaire and Bournville.

Share-holding and cooperative ownership have transformed the hierarchical structure on which that culture depended; service industries have driven manufacturing to the sidelines, and the workforce of a major industry may now be scattered across the globe. Those who own the capital may make none of the crucial decisions and enjoy few of the day-to-day rewards. Employees may receive health insurance as well as housing and pensions as part of their wage. They may even get shares in the firm.

Capitalism has adapted to the plans of those who have a stake in it, and is now regulated in ways that change the relation between workers and employers (who, in the larger businesses, are unlikely to be human individuals). The owner-worker relationship painted by Dickens and Zola has little place in a modern economy, and those who sniff in search of the old forms of cruel exploitation will be hard pressed to find them. Far easier to find them in the last remaining socialist economies like North Korea and Cuba, which illustrate that the alternative to the free economy is not ‘social ownership’ but slavery.

For all that, the critics of capitalism have a point. The separation of ownership from control, which seemed to spread the benefits of ownership beyond a small capitalist class, has also introduced new ways of taking the profits while handing on the cost. Members of a board can borrow against the capital, pay themselves bonuses, sell off all marketable assets, escape to their luxury yachts then file for bankruptcy. Those who acquire a firm may have no knowledge of where it is, what it is or whom it employs; they can freely ignore the pain of those whose livelihood they take away when they strip the assets and run.

The old fiduciary relationship means less and less in this debt-funded economy, which allows the easy sale and purchase of assets across frontiers, and the easy escape from duties (tax included) that come from being rooted in a place. Whether this is a fault of capitalism itself, rather than an abuse of it by global predators, is disputable. But it is clear that the free movement of capital and labour across frontiers, fundamental to the European treaties, has done much to undermine fiduciary relations. A humane capitalism retains its workforce through downturns, offers apprenticeships to local people and acts as a responsible citizen in places that depend upon it for prosperity and survival. But these obligations are easily ignored in favour of shareholder value when a firm’s administrative heart is located nowhere in particular, rather than in the somewhere of those who work for it.

In short, modern capitalism is a system devised for the benefit of absentees, which shields them from many of the real moral challenges. Victorian capitalists usually belonged to the same country, the same town and the same faith as those who worked for them, and could not escape, as their successors can, the demands of neighbourhood. Those who defend the new globalised capitalism must show how it might come down to earth, among the real people who depend on it.

Published in Spectator Life

Latest Articles

Advance Order: The Classical Vernacular: Architectural Principles in an Age of Nihilism.

  The Classical Vernacular Carcanet Press (1995)  We have requested a new print run of The Classical Vernacular and are taking advance orders.  The essays, from the perspective of 'the classical...

Press Statement 12th January 2020

Announcement 12th January 2020 It is with great sadness that we announce the death of Sir Roger Scruton, FBA, FRSL. Beloved husband of Sophie, adored father to Sam and Lucy...

A Christmas message

We mark the conclusion of a most interesting year by expressing sincere gratitude to all the many people who have sent messages of support and appreciation to Sir Roger, in...

Roger Scruton: A year in which much was lost – but more gained. The Spectator- 21 Dec 19

Despite everything, I have so much to be grateful for JanuaryMy 2018 ended with a hate storm, in response to my appointment as chair of the government’s Building Better, Building...

Recent Books

Notes from Underground

Beaufort Books  (2nd Edition October 2019) Set in the twilight years of the Czechoslovak communist regime, this novel describes a doomed love affair between two young people trapped by the...

Souls in the Twilight

Beaufort Books  (October 2018) As the lights that have guided us go out, people begin to wander in the twilight, seeking their place of belonging. In these stories, set in...

Music as an Art

Bloomsbury  (August 2018) Music as an Art begins by examining music through a philosophical lens, engaging in discussions about tonality, music and the moral life, music and cognitive science and German...

2019 Events

Wed 31st Jul - Fri 9th Aug - 2019 Scrutopia Summer School

Thur 29th Aug - Sun 1st Sept - Scrutopia Alumni Meeting 

Thurs 10th Oct - University of Buckingham London Programmes - Masters in Philosophy

Scrutopia Summer School Wed 29 July - Fri 7 August 2020